🔗 Share this article

Per developer statements from Embark Studios, Arc Raiders appears to make use of AI tools for generating certain dialogue. This development strongly echoes the debate that arose with the studio's earlier release, The Finals.

Game Overview

Debuted on October 30th for PlayStation 5, computer platforms, and Xbox, Arc Raiders is positioned as a easier on-ramp to the extraction shooter category. Unlike more hardcore titles like Escape from Tarkov, it aims to offer a user-friendly gameplay. The title has mostly received favorable reviews, presently achieving a excellent rating on the popular platform based on over 8,000 player reviews.

Development Approach

On the game's official store listing, a notice regarding "AI Generated Content" raises similarities: Throughout creation, we could utilize automated and generative tools to support material generation. Regardless of method, the end product embodies the artistic expression of our creative personnel."

Previous Controversy

The Finals, a well-received multiplayer first-person shooter famous for its fluid combat and dynamic battlefields, encountered backlash for its implementation of artificial intelligence even before its official launch. During its October 2023 open beta, the title's sound specialist revealed in a podcast interview that the company had used generative technology for creating voice content. This statement prompted immediate criticism from professional performers and creative personnel, who argued that AI-generated voices were of notably lower quality compared to actor deliveries and that such approaches could eliminate voice-acting jobs.

Company Position

Addressing concerns, the development team explained that they had hired professional performers to produce primary voice lines for The Finals, but enhanced these with text-to-speech tools to generate additional content modeled after those professional deliveries. The studio's rationale highlighted the production efficiency obtained via this technique.

Current Situation

About Arc Raiders, the title's creative lead commented that the title "in no way uses AI generation at all," though he avoided specifics on the specific interpretation of the Steam disclosure. He did admit, however, that the same vocal technology implemented in The Finals was also utilized in Arc Raiders.

We employ a blend of live performance content and content created through text-to-speech technology in our games, based on the context," stated a development team member. For specific scenarios, filming actual interactions where actors get together — allowing actor relationships and tension to define the final product — is something that adds depth to our virtual environments that systems cannot duplicate. In other instances, particularly if it involves dynamic gameplay announcements, TTS allows us to have tailored VO where we otherwise wouldn't for example due to development pace."

Gamer Feedback

First reactions to the use of automated systems in Arc Raiders has been fairly varied, particularly in the early days. A portion of the community have voiced significant concerns.

• Artificial intelligence dialogue is a blemish on an mostly outstanding title," wrote one user in a forum post.
• I oppose that they implemented it in The Finals and am disappointed to hear they did it again for this game," added another.
• The effect was instantly apparent in the vocal lines for one protagonist," observed a different user.

However, some users have expressed a more open-minded stance.

• It doesn't bother me, they compensated performers and applied it appropriately," commented one forum user.
• "This is as ethical as it gets these days, sadly," concluded another.

The continuing debate regarding artificial intelligence use in game development appears set to persist as studios juggle creative efficiency with creative quality and responsible practices.